Cover your spouse and or your husband! Cover your children! It is Speedy Onset Gender Dysphoria, aka ROGD, and its coming for your loved ones!
Or it is a whole bullshit time period coined by a physician who calls herself a researcher of “gender dysphoria, detransition, and desistance,” who made a spreadsheet of fogeys’ subjective beliefs about their kids and packaged it right into a narrative to feed a panic that hurts trans children. You be the choose!
In 2018, Dr. Lisa Littman of Brown College printed a paper positing that adolescent ladies had been transmitting transgenderism to one another by the use of social contagion, i.e. peer stress.
Here is how she described her function:
In on-line boards, dad and mom have reported that their kids appeared to expertise a sudden or fast onset of gender dysphoria, showing for the primary time throughout puberty and even after its completion. Mother and father describe that the onset of gender dysphoria appeared to happen within the context of belonging to a peer group the place one, a number of, and even the entire pals have turn into gender dysphoric and transgender-identified throughout the identical timeframe. Mother and father additionally report that their kids exhibited a rise in social media/web use previous to disclosure of a transgender id.
Because the dad or mum of three adolescents myself, let me level out that the chance that you simply, as a dad or mum, are a dependable reporter in your children’ good friend teams, a lot much less their social media habits, is about as excessive as BTS spontaneously exhibiting as much as play a live performance in your lounge. And no, I have not put this speculation to a rigorous, peer-reviewed scientific examine. In order that makes two of us.
Littman recruited members by inserting hyperlinks to a 90-question survey on “three web sites the place dad and mom and professionals had been noticed to explain what gave the impression to be a sudden or fast onset of gender dysphoria” and inspired the websites’ moderators and survey members to share the hyperlink with anybody they thought is likely to be — which is how you understand you are getting a consultant pattern set, proper?
However wait, there’s extra! As a result of the web sites, 4thwavenow, Transgendertrend, and the now-defunct YouthTransCriticalProfessionals.org “provided assist for folks, and expressed concern concerning the rush to diagnose younger folks as transgender and the frenzy to proceed to medical remedy for them,” as Littman herself put it.
You can be FOR SHOCKED to seek out that among the many 256 dad and mom on EeekMyKidIsTrans Dot Com who checked the bins “diagnosing” their kids with “fast onset gender dysphoria” — scare quotes as a result of that could be a time period Littman made up — a bunch of them thought their children caught the trans after getting in with a foul crowd. And since extra of the respondents had been assigned feminine intercourse at delivery (AFAB) relative to these assigned male intercourse at delivery (AMAB), she concluded that ladies, being extra inclined to see stress, had been trans-ing one another in highschool.
Yeah, it is actually that dumb. Amazingly, 63.8 % of the respondent dad and mom mentioned they’d been referred to as “transphobic” or “bigoted” by their kids. By which we imply, it is superb that 36.2 % of those children possessed such spectacular restraint.
The paper got here in for speedy criticism about its methodology, but in addition acquired Littman booked on Megyn Kelly’s show. So, you understand, either side.
However, as NBC flagged yesterday, a new paper from the American Academy of Pediatrics by Dr. Jack Turban of the College of California San Francisco completely debunks it, utilizing knowledge reported by children within the 2017 and 2019 Youth Danger Conduct Survey.
Wanna see what passes for a large subtweet within the medical career?
Of notice, this speculation was fashioned solely via the evaluation of on-line parental survey knowledge. As a subsequently issued correction to the article outlined, “ROGD will not be a proper psychological well being analysis presently. This report didn’t acquire knowledge from the adolescents and younger adults or clinicians and subsequently doesn’t validate the phenomenon.”
Regardless of this parent-centered examine prompting substantial social and methodological critique in tandem with requires extra strong analysis research with samples of TGD [transgender] adolescents, the notion of ROGD has been utilized in latest legislative debates to argue for and subsequently enact insurance policies that prohibit gender-affirming medical look after TGD adolescents. Notably, all related main medical organizations, together with the American Academy of Pediatrics, oppose such legislative efforts.
Translation: Your paper is trash and you must really feel horrible.
Play us extra of your epic diss observe, Doc:
Utilizing a nationwide pattern of United States adolescents, we discovered that there have been extra TGD [Assigned Male At Birth] adolescents than TGD [Assigned Female At Birth] adolescents in each 2017 and 2019. Moreover, the whole share of TGD adolescents in our pattern decreased from 2.4% in 2017 to 1.6% in 2019. This lower within the general share of adolescents figuring out as TGD is incongruent with an ROGD speculation that posits social contagion.
The AMAB:AFAB ratio, nonetheless in favor of extra TGD AMAB members for each years, shifted barely towards TGD AFAB members from 2017 to 2019. Importantly, this alteration was on account of a discount within the variety of TGD AMAB members, slightly than a rise in TGD AFAB members, once more arguing in opposition to a notion of social contagion with distinctive susceptibility amongst AFAB youth.
Ah, effectively, a lot for Littman’s principle a couple of wave of impressionable teen ladies giving one another the trans. Certainly it will shut the bigots up and put this nonsense to mattress about inclined teen ladies speaking one another into “changing into boys.”
Proper?
